49 Star Trek: Nemesis
Rewatch. The tenth Star Trek movie. The last based on The Next Generation. Picard and his crew are drawn into an unusual situation after a coup d'etat on Romulus. A situation that would have personal consequences for the Enterprise senior officers. Overall the situations presented are done well, but this presentation doesn't match up well compared to the quality of the previous The Next Generation films. Mainly this is because of the nature of the villain. Shizon as an abandoned clone of Picard?
The concept is not well developed. It could have been done a lot better. The Romulan plot from decades ago could have been detailed more. However, these issues doesn't make the film in any way unenjoyable. (It's just not as enjoyable as most other Star Trek films.) The way that the Thalaron Radiation works isn't developed either. With these quibbles aside, it is a good send off for the Next Generation crew, particularly Data. More on that later. Despite the quibbles about Shinzon's nature, Picard's response to this revelation is quite believable.
It is reasonable that he would want to compare himself and Shinzon. Their childhood's, their dreams etc. Of course, both are influenced by the environments. Picard as the explorer, due to the mostly peaceful nature of the Federation. Shinzon as a warrior due to his upbringing on Romulus and then Remus. Then there is Data and B4. Another mirror. And a foreshadowing of what is to come. The way Data went out, was true to his character. It was a sacrifice a human would have made. Then there are other developments, with Shinzon's Romulan 'allies'.
It is quite natural that they would want to betray Shinzon once his true motivations became known. There is more, but this what the movie is mostly about. (No need to question whether the Enterprise E actually has 29 decks!) As said above, the film isn't as good as most other Star Trek films, but still rewatchable. 7.25/10.
46 Star Trek: First Contact
Rewatch. The eighth Star Trek movie. The second based on The Next Generation. The Borg are back, and Picard is the only one who can stop them. Following up on the episodes where the Borg appeared in The Next Generation, the movie shows the Borg attacking the Federation again. Picard's distaste at Starfleet's attempt at keeping him from fighting the Borg is well presented (especially when he explains it to Riker in his ready room). The loyalty of his crew is shown when they are willing to follow his disobedience of Starfleet's orders.
The battle against the Cube in the Sol System is also shown rather well. The introduction of Worf on the Defiant is done rather well (with a brief return of the Klingon theme from The Motion Picture) in a way that establishes his character. The way the cube is defeated, with Picard 'hearing' the Collective and using it to the fleet's advantage is also done in a believable way. The progression from this to the Sphere traveling to the past is quite good. Picard is right to order the Enterprise to persue the Borg into the past, to change what they had done.
The situation caused by the Borg attack on the settlement around the Pheonix launch site is well presented. Cochrane's characterization as a reluctant figure, inventing the warp drive not to travel to the stars, but to get rich, is well done. He's more relatable than the 24th Century characters (who, as Picard tells Lily, more altruistic). The situation on the Enterprise, after the Borg begin to assimilate the ship, is suitably suspensive. In relation to this, the sequence on the deflector dish is well shot, with the stakes suitably high for such a sequence.
Data's experiences with the Borg Queen are also quite well done, building on his character development from the previous film. The launch of the Pheonix and the Borg Queen's attempt at destroying it are done well too. Overall it is a great film. 9/10.
45 Star Trek: Generations
Rewatch. The seventh Star Trek movie. The first based on The Next Generation. (Although not entirely). The film 'passes the torch' from the original cast to the Next Generation cast. Albeit not perfectly. It wasn't necessary to kill Kirk off. More on that later. But first, the scenes on the Enterprise B. These scenes are presented rather well. The nature (and existence) of the Nexus Ribbon is established, with Soran demanding to 'go back' there, from the start (and Guinan being one of the refugees).
The fact of the Enterprise B being ill-equipped to handle the rescue is well established. There is a feeling of peril as the ship rescues the El-Aurians and then gets stuck. The stress of the crew as they fight to get free is well portrayed. And Scotty's sadness at Kirk's (apparent) death is also well portrayed. In the 24th Century, the reasons for Data wanting to install his emotion chip are well developed. His wanting to become more human was a major theme in the tv series, so it is continued here.
The consequences of this action, resonate through the film, and show Brent Spiner's range as an actor. He was able to present the wide range of emotions rather well. Soran's plan is developed (not well, but it is developed) in away that doesn't cause problems with suspension of disbelief. The actions of the Duras Sisters are similarly developed, their reasons for what they are doing were established in the series. The crash of the Enterprise saucer was rather good, but I don't think it was necessary to destroy the Enterprise D.
It could have been used in the future movies. The scenes with Picard and Kirk were rather good, although Kirk could have had a more heroic death. Despite these quibbles it was a good beginning for the TNG crew. 8/10.

May 2025

S M T W T F S
     1 23
45 6 78910
11 12 13 141516 17
1819 2021 22 2324
25262728293031

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated May. 23rd, 2025 10:47 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios